margo

Running the shop

What to do when you get a bad review

The first hour, the three kinds of bad review and why each needs something different, the public reply, what Google will and will not remove, and the arithmetic of recovering a rating.

Bibin Mathew · 31 October 2026 · 12 min read

The short answer

Questions people ask

Should I reply to a bad review?+

Yes, once, publicly, briefly. An unanswered complaint is the loudest thing on your profile, and future clients read the reply more carefully than the review. They cannot tell whether the complaint was fair; they can tell exactly how you behave when criticised.

Can I get a bad review removed from Google?+

Only if it breaks a policy: fake, spam, off-topic, abusive, posted by a competitor, or containing personal details. Being unfair, wrong about the facts or harsh is not a policy breach, and reporting it on those grounds will fail. Report it, appeal once if it is rejected, then move on.

How long does Google take to remove a reported review?+

Anywhere from a couple of days to several weeks, often with no explanation either way. Treat removal as a bonus rather than a plan, and get on with the reply and the client in the meantime.

Should I offer a refund to someone who left a bad review?+

Offer the fix first, which is usually a redo with you or your most senior person. A refund is the right answer when the work cannot be put right, when they do not want to come back, or when you would rather end it cleanly. Never make either one conditional on the review being changed.

How much does one bad review actually hurt?+

Far less than it feels, and the damage shrinks as your review count grows. One one-star review takes a profile with twenty five-star reviews from 5.0 to 4.8. The same review on a profile with a hundred barely moves the number at all. Volume is the real defence.

What if the review is about a member of staff?+

Reply as the business, never name them publicly, never confirm or deny who it was. Deal with it internally, and tell the person it is about before they read it on their phone at home.

Can I threaten legal action over a false review?+

You can, and it almost always costs more than the review did. A legal threat tends to make a quiet complaint into a public story. If someone is repeatedly making false factual claims that are damaging your business, that is a conversation for a solicitor, not for the reply box.

Keep reading