Running the shop
What to do when you get a bad review
The first hour, the three kinds of bad review and why each needs something different, the public reply, what Google will and will not remove, and the arithmetic of recovering a rating.
Bibin Mathew · 31 October 2026 · 12 min read
The short answer
- Do nothing for the first hour. Nothing written while you are angry will read the way you intend.
- Reply once, publicly, briefly, and move the detail somewhere private. Future clients read the reply more carefully than the complaint.
- Google removes policy breaches, not unfairness. Fake, spam, off-topic, abusive, competitor-posted or containing personal details — being wrong about the facts is not on the list.
- One one-star review takes a profile with twenty five-star reviews from 5.0 to 4.8. The same review against a hundred barely moves the number. Volume is the real defence.
- Never make a refund or a redo conditional on the review being changed.
Nobody warns you how physical it feels. You open your phone between clients, see the notification, read eleven sentences about yourself written by someone who was in your chair last Tuesday, and then you have to go and do a fringe.
Every appointment business gets them. A profile with nothing but five stars is less convincing than one with a handful of mixed reviews handled well, because the first looks curated and the second looks real. That is genuinely true, and it is no comfort whatsoever in the first hour.
So: the first hour, then the work.
The first hour: do nothing
Not as a wellbeing tip. As a business decision.
The reply you want to write in the first hour is the reply that costs you clients. It contains the words “actually”, “as I explained at the time”, and a timeline. It is accurate and it is a disaster, because of the single most important thing to understand about review replies:
The audience is not the reviewer. It is the person comparing three salons next March, who will read the complaint, then read your reply, and decide which of the two sounds like a business they want to sit in for two hours.
That person cannot possibly judge whether the complaint was fair. They were not there. What they can judge, in about four seconds, is whether you seem like someone who handles things or someone who argues.
So: screenshot it, put the phone down, finish your day. Reply tomorrow morning. Nothing bad happens in twelve hours; a great deal of bad happens in twelve minutes.
Three kinds, and they are not the same problem
Owners tend to treat every bad review as one event. They are three, and conflating them is why replies go wrong.
1. The fair one
Something went wrong. You were running forty minutes late, the colour was not what they asked for, the junior left them under the dryer, you were short with them because it was the fourth difficult thing that day.
This is the easiest one, and the one owners handle worst, because it stings most. It is also the one with the biggest upside: a fairly-earned complaint, answered well and fixed properly, often ends with the client back in the chair and a second review saying so. That sequence is worth more than a smooth appointment ever was.
2. The unfair one
They are wrong about the facts. They were twenty minutes late and are complaining the appointment was rushed. They asked for exactly what they got and changed their mind in the car park. They are angry about a price that was in the confirmation, the window and the price list.
You will not win this one, and that is fine, because you are not playing against them. Reply as though it were mostly fair — brief, unbothered, no correction — and let the contrast between their eleven sentences and your two do the work. Readers are better at spotting an unreasonable reviewer than you think, as long as you have not given them a second unreasonable person to look at.
The exception worth one short clause: if they state something factually wrong that would genuinely mislead a reader, correct that one fact, neutrally, once. “We’re open until six on Saturdays” is a fact. “The appointment wasn’t rushed” is an argument.
3. The fake one
Nobody of that name has ever been in. It is a competitor, a bot, an ex-employee, or someone reviewing the wrong business entirely.
This is the only kind where removal is a realistic goal, and it is also the kind where you must not say so in public. “We have no record of this client” is probably true and reads to every stranger as a dodge. Report it, and reply with something that works whether or not it is genuine: see below.
Work out which of the three you have before you type anything. The reply differs, the private follow-up differs, and only one of them is worth reporting.
The public reply
Four sentences, maximum. Here is the shape, and then the variants.
I’m sorry — that’s not the experience we want anyone to have. I’d like to put it right, and I’ve sent you a message so we can sort it out directly.
That is it. Note what is absent: the client’s version of events, your version of events, the word “however”, any detail at all.
For the fair one, name the thing, briefly, because naming it is what makes the apology land:
You’re right that we were running late and I’m sorry — that’s on me, not on you. I’d like to redo it properly with you. I’ve messaged you to find a time that works.
Naming it costs you nothing with readers and buys you a great deal. An apology that refuses to say what for reads as a form letter.
For the unfair one, warmth and brevity, no correction:
I’m sorry you left feeling that way. That’s not how I’d want anyone to go home. I’ve sent you a message — I’d genuinely like to hear more and see what we can do.
For the one you believe is fake, write something true that costs nothing either way:
We don’t have a record of this appointment, so I may be looking in the wrong place. If you’ve been in, please message us directly and we’ll look into it properly.
Then report it and stop thinking about it. One line, no accusation, and an open door that a real client will walk through and a fake one never will.
What loses you more business than the review did
- Arguing the facts. Even when you are right. Especially when you are right.
- Length. Four paragraphs reads as a business with time to litigate rather than fix.
- Copy-and-paste. Six identical replies in a row tells a reader nobody is actually reading.
- “As I said in the salon…” Re-litigating a conversation nobody else witnessed.
- Silence. The default outcome, and the worst one.
- Replying twice. If they come back at you in a second review or a reply, let it stand. The reader is already on your side by then; a second round hands it back.
The private conversation
The public reply exists for strangers. The actual resolution happens somewhere else, and it is worth doing properly, because a client who is put right tends to tell people — and because the alternative is someone who stays angry about you locally for years.
Lead with the fix, not the money.
Hi Jo — thanks for coming back to me. I’d rather put this right than leave it. Can you come in Thursday or Saturday morning and I’ll sort the colour myself, no charge? If you’d rather not come back in, I completely understand and I’ll refund the colour instead.
Why this order:
- The redo is usually what they actually want. They came to you for a result and have not got it. Most people take the appointment.
- It costs you time, not margin. A refund costs you the money and the chance to turn it round.
- The refund is offered, not extracted. Saying it yourself removes the fight, and the ones who take it were never coming back anyway.
Two hard rules:
Never make anything conditional on the review. “I’ll refund you if you take the review down” is the one sentence that turns a complaint into a story they tell, and in many places it is also a line you do not want to be on the wrong side of. Fix it because it needs fixing. Some people will edit the review on their own and plenty will not.
Decide your ceiling before you open the thread. Write down what you are willing to do — redo, refund the service, refund the lot, nothing — and then hold it warmly. Negotiating under pressure in a live chat at nine at night is how people end up refunding three appointments and a taxi.
And occasionally the right answer is: nothing. Someone who wants a free appointment every visit, who has done this before, who is abusive — a polite, final, “I’m sorry we couldn’t make it work; I don’t think we’re the right salon for you” is a legitimate end to it. That conversation is cleaner when your terms were clear from the start, which is most of what a cancellation and no-show policy is actually for.
What Google will actually remove
Worth knowing precisely, because most of the energy owners spend here is spent on the wrong grounds.
| Likely removed | Not removed |
|---|---|
| Fake or spam, no appointment ever existed | Unfair, one-sided or exaggerated |
| Posted by a competitor (conflict of interest) | Wrong about the facts, in your view |
| Off-topic — nothing to do with the business | Harsh, blunt or emotional |
| Abuse, slurs, threats | One star with no words |
| Personal details, or naming a staff member’s private life | About the price |
| The same review posted repeatedly | Left after you declined something |
Report it from your Business Profile, choose the ground that genuinely applies, and expect anywhere between a few days and several weeks, frequently with no explanation. If it is rejected and you are confident it breaks a policy, there is an appeal, and it is worth exactly one attempt.
What does not work: reporting on the grounds that it is unfair, flagging it from five different accounts, asking clients to report it en masse, or paying anyone who promises review removal. That last one is a straightforward scam, and the inverse service — buying positive reviews — is detectable, against the policies and obvious to human readers from the writing style. Why gating and incentives cost more than they gain covers the same ground from the other direction.
These policies change. Current as of October 2026; check Google’s own review policies for what applies today.
Elsewhere: Facebook, Instagram, and your own DMs
Instagram has no review system at all, which surprises people. What it has instead is comments and DMs, and those behave very differently.
- A comment on a post. Reply once, publicly, in the same register as a review reply, then take it to DMs. Deleting it is occasionally right — abuse, slurs, another client’s personal details — and usually wrong, because people notice and screenshot. Hiding a comment is gentler than deleting it and does not notify them.
- A DM. This is the best possible outcome: a complaint nobody else can see. Answer it properly and fast. A complaint in your inbox at eleven at night that gets no reply for two days is how a DM becomes a one-star review.
- Facebook recommendations. Same approach, same reporting route, less traffic.
The pattern worth noticing: every complaint that reaches you privately is a review that did not get written. Which makes the speed of your inbox a reputation tool and not just a service one. The DMs that arrive when you are closed is mostly about bookings, and this is the other half of why the overnight gap matters.
The arithmetic, which is more cheering than it feels
Do this, because the fear is always bigger than the number.
A profile with 20 five-star reviews sits at 5.0. Add one one-star and it is 4.8.
To get back to 4.9 from there you need 19 more five-star reviews. That sounds brutal until you notice the real lesson, which is not about recovery:
The same one-star review on a profile with 100 reviews takes it from 5.0 to 4.96 — which displays as 5.0. It is invisible.
So the defence against bad reviews is not handling them brilliantly. It is having so many that one cannot matter. A shop that asks every happy client, every week, has a profile where a bad review is a line of text a careful reader finds, considers, and weighs against ninety-six others. A shop with eleven reviews has a profile where a bad review is a third of the page.
That is a habit, not a crisis response, and it has to be running before you need it. How to ask, and the window where people actually do it.
One more thing the arithmetic hides: recency is weighted by readers even when it is not weighted by the algorithm. A bad review from March, sitting under four good ones from this month, is read as “they had an off day once”. The same review at the top of the list is read as the current state of the business. Collecting steadily is what pushes it down the page.
When it is not a bad review, it is feedback
The case nobody wants to consider.
If you have three reviews in six months all mentioning waiting, or all mentioning being rushed, or all mentioning the price being different from what they expected — that is not a run of unreasonable clients. That is your shop telling you something in the only channel it has.
Read them as a set, once a quarter, looking for the repeated word. The usual culprits are dull and fixable:
- Running late, because the slot length does not match the real appointment. Which is also the thing that quietly underprices your long services.
- Price surprise, because the number was never written down anywhere they would have seen it. Why hiding prices costs more than it protects.
- Felt rushed, same cause as running late, different symptom.
- Nobody replied, because the enquiry arrived at nine at night and got buried.
Fixing the repeated word does more for your rating over a year than any reply you will ever write.
The checklist
- Screenshot it, then put the phone down until tomorrow
- Decide which of the three it is before typing
- Reply once, publicly, four sentences maximum
- Name the thing if it was fair; correct nothing if it was not
- Never “we have no record of this client” in public
- Move all detail to a private channel
- Offer the fix before the money, and decide your ceiling first
- Nothing offered is ever conditional on the review
- Report it only on a ground that genuinely applies, appeal once, then let go
- Tell any member of staff it concerns before they find it themselves
- Never reply twice
- Read your bad reviews as a set every quarter and fix the repeated word
- Ask every happy client, every week, so the next one cannot matter
The businesses that look unbothered by bad reviews are not calmer than you. They just have ninety more reviews than you, collected one at a time, in the months when it did not appear to be doing anything.
Questions people ask
Should I reply to a bad review?+
Yes, once, publicly, briefly. An unanswered complaint is the loudest thing on your profile, and future clients read the reply more carefully than the review. They cannot tell whether the complaint was fair; they can tell exactly how you behave when criticised.
Can I get a bad review removed from Google?+
Only if it breaks a policy: fake, spam, off-topic, abusive, posted by a competitor, or containing personal details. Being unfair, wrong about the facts or harsh is not a policy breach, and reporting it on those grounds will fail. Report it, appeal once if it is rejected, then move on.
How long does Google take to remove a reported review?+
Anywhere from a couple of days to several weeks, often with no explanation either way. Treat removal as a bonus rather than a plan, and get on with the reply and the client in the meantime.
Should I offer a refund to someone who left a bad review?+
Offer the fix first, which is usually a redo with you or your most senior person. A refund is the right answer when the work cannot be put right, when they do not want to come back, or when you would rather end it cleanly. Never make either one conditional on the review being changed.
How much does one bad review actually hurt?+
Far less than it feels, and the damage shrinks as your review count grows. One one-star review takes a profile with twenty five-star reviews from 5.0 to 4.8. The same review on a profile with a hundred barely moves the number at all. Volume is the real defence.
What if the review is about a member of staff?+
Reply as the business, never name them publicly, never confirm or deny who it was. Deal with it internally, and tell the person it is about before they read it on their phone at home.
Can I threaten legal action over a false review?+
You can, and it almost always costs more than the review did. A legal threat tends to make a quiet complaint into a public story. If someone is repeatedly making false factual claims that are damaging your business, that is a conversation for a solicitor, not for the reply box.