Compare
Margo vs paying someone to answer your DMs
A VA answers in real sentences and uses judgement, which no software fully replaces. Where the maths turns, what tends to go wrong, and why a lot of shops end up with both.
What a virtual assistant is good at
A person is better than any software at the things that are actually hard. They can tell that a client is upset before she says so, talk somebody out of a colour that will not work on her hair, notice that the woman asking about bridal is the same woman who came in about her daughter’s prom, and write a reply that sounds like a human being because it is one. They can also do the rest of the job — chase a supplier, sort the rota, post the Stories. Margo answers DMs. That is all she does.
Where Margo is different
The difference is cover and cost, not capability. A good VA working twenty hours a week is excellent for twenty hours and absent for the other hundred and forty-eight — including the eight-to-eleven window when most salon enquiries actually arrive. Margo is mediocre at judgement and awake at 11pm on a Sunday, which happens to be when a lot of appointments are decided.
Rates and the going cost of cover vary enormously by where you hire and what you need; treat the numbers here as a shape, not a quote.
Where the arithmetic actually turns
Work out the real cost of the cover you need, not the hourly rate. Evening and weekend hours are when the enquiries land, which is also when help is most expensive and least reliable. Twenty hours a week at a sensible rate is a meaningful monthly number, and it buys you twenty hours — not a response time.
Then put it against what the DMs are worth. If forty people message you a month and you convert half, the ones you lose to a slow reply are the whole argument. A shop at a £45 average ticket losing six enquiries a month to “sorry, just seen this” is losing more than the software costs by an order of magnitude, and less than a part-time person costs.
That is the band where this decision lives. Below it, answer them yourself. Above it — genuinely complex consultations, or enough volume that someone is doing it full time — hire the person. In the middle, which is where most single-site shops sit, the software wins on cover rather than on cleverness.
What tends to go wrong with the person
Not competence. The two failures that actually show up are drift and turnover. Drift is a VA quoting last season’s price because the price list lives in your head and the update never reached them — the same failure mode as a stale automation, and just as invisible until a client is in the chair expecting the old number.
Turnover is worse, because the training was the asset. Six months of knowing that you do not do box-dye corrections and that Tuesday mornings are for regulars walks out of the door, and you start again. Shops that have been through it twice are usually the ones asking about software.
The fix for both is the same thing and it is worth doing regardless of what you decide here: write the business down. Services, durations, prices, what you will and will not take on, policies, the answers to the ten questions you are asked most. That document is what you train a person with, and it is exactly what Margo reads. Doing it is not wasted either way.
Most shops end up with both
This is not really an either-or, and presenting it as one would be selling you something. The arrangement that works is software taking the first reply and the repetitive middle, and a person — you, or someone you pay — taking the conversations that need a human.
That is what the handoff is for. Margo answers the price question, offers two real times, books it, and the moment somebody is unhappy, asking about something off the menu, or clearly needs talking through a decision, it stops being her conversation and lands on your phone with the thread attached. Nobody is pretending otherwise to the client.
The practical effect is that a part-time person stops spending their hours typing opening times and starts spending them on the conversations worth their judgement. If you already have someone good, that is an argument for keeping them, not for replacing them.
Switch to Margo if…
- Most of your enquiries arrive outside anyone’s working hours
- The questions are repetitive — price, duration, availability, parking
- You have trained someone up twice already and would rather not do it again
- The cost of the cover you actually need is more than the appointments it wins
Stay with a virtual assistant if…
- Your enquiries are complex consultations rather than price-and-time questions
- You need someone doing the other parts of the job too
- Your clients are high-value enough that every conversation deserves a person
We would rather you used the right tool than the one we sell. If the list above describes you, a virtual assistant is the better choice.
Moving over from a virtual assistant
Keep whoever you have while you set this up; there is no switchover moment and nothing to cancel. Ask them for the list of questions they answer most and whatever notes they work from — that is the fastest possible start on Margo’s service list and FAQ, better than anything she can draft from your profile. Then connect Instagram, correct the draft, and run her in the test chat. When she goes live, have the handoff point at your assistant rather than at you if that suits better: they pick up the conversations that need a person and stop retyping your opening hours.
Questions people ask
Will clients notice it is not a person?+
Some will, and Margo is upfront about it if asked — she does not claim to be a human. What clients react to much more strongly is being answered at all, and being answered in a minute rather than tomorrow.
Can my assistant still use the inbox?+
Yes. You both see every conversation, either of you can take over mid-thread, and Margo steps back when a person replies. Saved replies and labels are there for whoever is working the inbox.
What happens to the messages Margo cannot handle?+
They are handed over with the whole thread, and you get a notification. That is the designed outcome rather than a failure — a conversation that needs judgement should reach a person quickly, not get an answer that sounds confident and is wrong.
What does Margo cost?+
There’s a free plan, and Pro is $19/month at launch (usually $29). Pricing is on the homepage.